Our Locations

Columbus, IN Office

911 25th Street
Columbus, IN

Get Directions
  • Auto Insurance

    Accidents on the road happen every day. However, when you have an experienced and caring agency by your side, the unexpected does not stand a chance. Learn more about your auto insurance options, today.

  • Business Insurance

    At Zeller Insurance, we make it our business to get to know YOUR business. It is our mission to learn about your company from top to bottom in order to provide you with top-notch solutions. Let’s get started!

  • Home Insurance

    Your home is your safe haven. You may feel like you are the only one who cares about its security, but at Zeller Insurance, we care. Let’s find you the perfect policy for your beautiful home, today.

  • Specialty Insurance

    Our agents are committed to making sure each and every policy is special—especially when it comes to specialty markets. From golf courses to condo associations, we can provide you with tailored commercial insurance services.

Welcome to Zeller Insurance, the Indiana agency that is there for you every step of the way!

Founded in 1972 by Bill Zeller, Zeller Insurance continues to run as a full-service independent insurance agency, located in the city of Columbus and serving the entire state of Indiana. As an independent agency, we represent a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable insurance companies. In other words, we do not work for the insurance company; we work for you.

Our team of licensed insurance agents is proud to have over 200 years of combined experience in the insurance industry. Having this experience alongside our superior customer service, the Indiana community can rest assured when it comes to coverage. At Zeller Insurance, we are truly committed to the highest standard of excellence and we pride ourselves on establishing solid, long-lasting relationships with our clientele.

Allow Us to Bundle Your Needs for You

Our agency understands that there are many precious parts that make up your life—and each area must be protected. This is why we encourage our clients to bundle their needs for a simple, easy solution. Our agency can offer a wide variety of both personal and business insurance solutions. For individuals and families, we can bundle your auto, home, and life insurance needs. This may not only reduce coverage gaps, but could save you money. If you have a business, our agency can cover your company, too. We strive to protect your life as a whole.

Business owners are in luck. We not only write the basics such as general liability and workers compensation, but can design tailored packages for those in specialized industries, from public entity businesses to contractors. Once you have a protection plan in place, we can then provide your company with an exclusive employee benefits package. There is a policy for everyone.

At Zeller Insurance, We Take Care of You

We want to make sure that our community is taken care of. If you are ready to learn more about the insurance solutions that we can offer you, your families, and your business, please reach out to our agents at your earliest convenience to chat or to simply grab a free quote. It is our mission to get to know you and your needs in order to design a “perfect fit” policy to bring you peace of mind.