INSURANCE AGENCY in Columbus, IN

Flexible insurance from a team you can trust.

Being an independent agency means we shop and compare the best insurance options on your behalf to find the best combination of cost and coverage. If you're looking for a better insurance experience, you'll love doing business with us.

YouTube video

Start A Conversation With Our Friendly Team

Enter some basic information to get started, and our team will take it from there!
Start Quotes Here

Jeff Hoeltke

Always the best and always taken care of!!

Cherie Hill

Have always received quick and courteous service from all of the agents from whom I've dealt with over the years there and am quite pleased with the competitive pricing on our coverage.

Donna Booth

I have worked with Lori Rowan for years. She is quick to respond and always shops around to find us the best rates. I highly recommend Zeller Insurance Agency!

Sandy Caldwell

Great people great service. Always recommend them.

Kelly Geckler

Zeller Insurance is great to work with. I love having a real people, locally where I live in Columbus, Indiana to help me with all my insurance needs.

Jason Smith

We saved quite a bit of money and the service is great.

Diana Biddle

Top notch customer service. Quality engagement matching consumer with the best products available for the best price. Highly recommend!

Karen Ferguson

Greg Allen has a been above and beyond helping me out with everything that I had questions about and any new changes that I might have with my insurance. He is superb.

Even more reasons to choose our insurance agency if you live in Columbus or surrounding areas

Choosing the right insurance policy can be a daunting task even for a well informed consumer. Image if you have no idea what you're doing?

At Zeller Insurance, our main goal is the make the process as easy, educational, and enjoyable as possible, with personalized and authentic advice from an experienced agent, who goes to bat for customers, and does the right thing every day.

One of the biggest reasons you would want to use an independent agent like us, is we work and live in your community, so you're supporting local economy and small business.

You're never just a number at Zeller Insurance!

Choice

Being Independent means that we don't work for any one insurance company. We have the ability to search multiple companies on your behalf, acting as a negotiator, to find you the best possible policy and price. You never have to haggle with an agent or insurance company again.

Expertise

Not all insurance agencies are created equal. We have an in-depth knowledge of insurance policy coverages from dozens of different insurance companies. We've seen it all, and when it comes to fine print, we truly understand the coverage we are recommending.

Service

Why sit on hold with a call center representative who doesn't know you, when you can deal with a familiar face who knows you and understands your unique situation? Our customer service is the single biggest reason why our customers refer us so many of their friends.

Claims

The entire reason you have insurance is for when you need to use it. Unfortunately, insurance contracts contain many exclusions and conditions you may be unaware of. We'll help you understand how you're covered, and walk you through your claim.

Local

When you do business with our agency, you're not only supporting your local community, but you're being serviced by a local business who knows your name, and your unique coverage needs. You never have to deal with call-center representatives again.

insurance choices

Insurance is never just about price, but we're really good at saving money.

There are many factors that go into insurance rates, and it's no secret that rates increase every so often. Our mission among other things is to help individuals and business-owners put money back in their pockets.

Insurance doesn't have to be complicated. With us, it isn't.

Insurance can be overwhelmingly confusing. All of the jargon, terms, and coverages can make you feel like you don't understand any of it. Our team educates our clients so they fully understand what their premium dollars are being spent on.

  • Annual
    0%
    Savings
  • Coverage
    0%
    Improvement

Why choose us? We believe in old-fashioned customer
service along with a few other core beliefs -

  • Efficiency

    Your time is valuable, so we work quick to deliver results.

  • Clarity

    Insurance can be confusing, we'll make it easy to understand.

  • Honesty

    When other agencies sell you what you don't need, we don't.

Our friendly & knowledgable team is our greatest competitive advantage.

What makes one insurance agency different from all the rest? Simple - people, personality, and professionalism. At Zeller Insurance, we go above and beyond to ensure your experience with us is one you won't forget.

Insurance concept. Protection against a possible eventuality. Hand holding umbrella icon and House, Car, Family and Health icon on wooden block for assurance life concept.
nordwood-themes-q8U1YgBaRQk-unsplash

Are you an existing agency client in need of policy support?

Depending on what type of request you have, it may be fulfilled by our in-house team of CSRs (customer support representatives) or by your insurance carrier directly. If you have an emergency claim, we'd recommend contacting your carrier directly.

Personal & Commercial Insurance Simplified

At Zeller Insurance we have access to a wide range of both insurance carriers and products. This gives us, and more importantly, you, flexibility and choice when it comes to your coverages and company.

Personal Insurance

Whether its home, auto, renters, boat or flood, we can help protect you and your family with custom coverages.

Commercial Insurance

We protect hundreds of businesses, large and small. From Tradesmen to Lawyers, we've got you covered.

Medicare Insurance

We help Medicare eligible individuals find the best Medicare plans available for their needs.

Start A Conversation With Us

Enter some basic information to get started, and our helpful team will take it from there!
Start Quotes Here
Call Email Claims Payments